After Shipwreck, Lebanese Survivors Return to Poverty

  • W460
  • W460

Assaad Assaad sold everything to escape poverty in Lebanon, but now he is back, after watching his wife and three children, and his dreams of a better life, perish at sea.

The 36-year-old, who could now pass for 50, was among 18 shell-shocked Lebanese who returned on Sunday after surviving a shipwreck off Indonesia that killed dozens of impoverished migrants from the Middle East.

The Lebanese aboard the Australia-bound boat mainly hailed from the northern Akkar region, where an influx of refugees from neighboring Syria has compounded the endemic poverty of one of the country's poorest areas.

"We were desperate to leave, and we had hope for a better life, because there is nothing for us here," Assaad said as he stared ahead blankly, still reliving the tragedy.

"I lost everything -- my wife, my children, my home," he says, sitting in his parents' modest house where the crushing silence is only occasionally broken by neighbors calling in to quietly offer their condolences.

In Kabiit, a village nestled beneath verdant mountains, Assaad supported his family on $13 a day before deciding to sell everything -- his house, his car, his land and his cow -- to pay for passage to Australia, the "Eden" to which many of his fellow villagers had gone.

"I don't want to be rich. I just want to live decently. Here we live in humiliation," he said.

Criminal networks have descended on the region to take advantage of Syrians fleeing the civil war, offering cut-rate passage to Australia via Indonesia that has encouraged poor Lebanese to try their luck as well.

"Many of those who left lead good lives now. We were not so lucky," said Assaad, who paid $70,000 to smugglers.

He describes the moment when he lost everything.

"It was like an explosion. The boat just disintegrated. It was indescribable," he said. "I would have preferred to die with my family."

Between 80 and 120 people, most of them from the Middle East, were on board the boat. Twenty-eight bodies, many of them women and children, were recovered but 22 others are still missing.

Assaad wants the state to "open its eyes" to the situation in Akkar, where residents are forced to work the land or, in his case, fell trees for charcoal.

In Kabiit -- three hours north of Beirut -- pot-holed streets run past shuttered shops and children fill plastic bottles with water from a public tap before hauling them back to homes without plumbing.

The closest hospital is 20 kilometers (12 miles) away.

Even after the tragedy off Indonesia, many locals say they are still willing to try their luck on the ocean passage, fearing that if they remain they could lose even their limited livelihoods to Syrian refugees.

Fahed Kassem, 36, says he struggles to make ends meet with the $800 a month he earns at a metallurgical plant in Beirut.

"Now my boss tells me he could have four Syrians in my place," he said. "If the opportunity presents itself, I would emigrate too."

Hussein Khodr gave similar reasons for leaving before he set off on the "ship of death" with his eight children and pregnant wife, all of whom died.

"He was overwhelmed, he wanted to leave everything. He said 'I want to live well or I want to die'," his father Ahmad said.

Lebanon is home to 770,000 refugees, and has been without a government for six months after a political crisis caused in part by its ever-feuding political factions' support for rival sides in Syria.

The conflict has spilled over into Lebanon in the form of clashes between armed groups, rocket attacks and bombings that have raised fears of a return to civil war.

Afrah Hassan, a 22-year-old who survived the shipwreck, was studying law at a university in the northern city of Tripoli, where fighting has repeatedly broken out between supporters and opponents of Syria's President Bashar Assad.

"There was shooting all the time, and sometimes we had to hide under our chairs in the classroom," she said. "It was too much. I wanted to leave everything."

She remembers the cockroaches in the boat, five days in which she saw only sky and sea, and then the 10-meter-high (30-foot) waves that crashed into the ship, the small children floating lifeless in the churning waters.

"There is no horizon in Lebanon, it's true," she said. "But now I tell myself I never should have left."

Comments 8
Default-user-icon Tia (Guest) 07 October 2013, 11:33

Australia has a newly elected Government with a new illegal immigration policy. These measures have been taken after more than 50,000 people have arrived illegally by boat in the last 5 years and THOUSANDS of men, woman and children have died trying.

NO illegal immigrant arriving by boat will ever, EVER be granted Australian citizenship. ALL illegal boat arrivals are processed offshore and settled in countries other than Australia.

If you pay a people smuggler money - you will end up in a detention camp awaiting settlement in a country other than Australia. GUARANTEED.

You will NEVER be legally allowed to settle in Australia - this is now the LAW. ** DON'T RISK YOUR MONEY OR YOUR LIVES **

Thumb benzona 07 October 2013, 15:13

Y'a latif, que Dieu aide ces rescapés. Lebanon can't/won't do anything for them.... Lebanon only takes thing from people, it doesn't give. I speak from a personal experience.

Default-user-icon MadeinLB (Guest) 07 October 2013, 17:12

So sad and true.

Thumb haile.selassie. 07 October 2013, 15:26

southern do you believe that exploration of oil will make us richer?? yes there will be new projects and stuff but the political class is the only beneficiary and the poor will remain poor trust me.

Thumb lebanon_first 07 October 2013, 16:13

Poverty is unbearable to poor people in lebanon because everyone around poor people is pretending to have more money that he really has.
Those poor people would not consider bicycling to work, or holding on getting children, while getting their wives to work as domestic workers for a few years, or not buying a (used) BMW, or forgoing the 3 packs of cigarettes a day.

The societal pressures are such that a lifestyle that would be considered lower middle class in egypt is considered unbearably poor in lebanon.

Default-user-icon Maha (Guest) 07 October 2013, 16:40

Lebanon_first, I think this is another level of poor here. The areas in akkar have never had electricity or running water. I dont think the likes of you and me could imagine ourelves living like that. These people are what you see on TV in Africa or "in a land far far away". Well its not, its right here in Lebanon and it breaks the heart.

Thumb cityboy 07 October 2013, 20:27

LF couldn't agree more!!

Default-user-icon trueself (Guest) 07 October 2013, 18:52

Sad and heart bleeding stories of people who sold everything to go and die a horrible death in the sea. If our politicians have a drop of dignity and humanity, they should stop all the war machines they are waging everyday and look at their people who are suffering and have nowhere to go. No Iran or saudi Arabia will help solve the problems of Lebanon. A part of the lebanese is taking lebanon to unknown territory, one that's full of destruction and economic disaster. When are we going to be a one nation that only cares for its wellbeing?