Activists Slam 'Charade' as Sawwan Removed from Beirut Blast Probe


Rights defenders condemned a "mockery of justice" after a Lebanese court Thursday removed the judge leading a probe into the massive blast at Beirut's port last August.

Lebanese authorities have come under increasing pressure to provide answers over the August 4 explosion of hundreds of tons of ammonium nitrate on the dockside that killed more that 200 people, injured thousands and ravaged large parts of the capital.

But Fadi Sawwan's removal, after two former ministers he had charged with negligence in the case filed a complaint, risks bringing the whole investigation back to square one.

On Thursday, "the Cassation Court decided to transfer the investigation... from Sawwan to another judge," a judicial source said.

The court ruling found in favor of the plaintiffs who had questioned the judge's impartiality in view of his home having been damaged in the explosion, the source said.

Rights activists condemned Thursday's ruling as the latest example of an entrenched political class placing itself above the law.

Sawwan's removal "makes a mockery of justice and is an insult to the victims of the blast," Human Rights Watch researcher Aya Majzoub said.

The ruling showed "politicians are not subject to the rule of law," she added.

On December 10, Sawwan had issued charges against caretaker Prime Minister Hassan Diab and three former ministers for "negligence and causing death to hundreds," triggering outrage from politicians.

Premier-designate Saad Hariri and Hizbullah were among those to oppose the indictment.

Among those charged were former finance minister Ali Hassan Khalil and ex-public works minister Ghazi Zoaiter, who accused Sawwan of violating the constitution on the grounds of immunity and moved to have him removed from the case.

- 'Charade needs to end' -

Majzoub said: "More than six months later, we are back to square one."

"This charade needs to end... We need an international, independent investigation as soon as possible."

Lawyer and activist Nizar Saghieh said he needed to see the full court decision, but feared the worst.

"By refusing to be held accountable, the ministers and political class are drawing a red line in the investigation," he told AFP.

He said it was a typical pattern in Lebanon that "prevents any justice from being achieved."

The probe into Lebanon's worst peace-time disaster has led to the detention of 25 people, from maintenance workers to the port's customs director, but not a single politician.

It has focused mainly on who was to blame for the fertilizer being left to languish unsafely at the port for more than six years, not how the ammonium nitrate ended up in Beirut.

On Monday, however, Sawwan requested information from Lebanese security forces on three Syrian businessman thought to be behind the procurement of the fertilizer shipment that arrived on a dilapidated ship from Georgia in 2013.

Comments 3
Thumb 18 February 2021, 18:23

Scandalous! Unacceptable! Disgusting!

Thumb chrisrushlau 18 February 2021, 18:57

Sawan charged three ex-ministers and caretaker prime minister Hassan Diab in December with negligence over the Aug. 4 explosion, the largest non-nuclear blast in history, that has further exacerbated strains on a country struggling with its worst crisis since the 1975-1990 civil war....Two of the others charged Ali Hassan Khalil, a former finance minister, and Ghazi Zeaiter, a former public works minister said in December they had not been officially informed of the call for questioning, which protocol demanded....Both Khalil and Zeaiter are lawmakers from Amal, the Shi'ite party led by powerful Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri, who is allied to Shi'ite Hezbollah, which Washington considers a terrorist organization. Amal has accused Sawan of breaching the constitution. (Reuters)

Thumb chrisrushlau 18 February 2021, 18:57

The third former minister, Youssef Finianos, a Hezbollah ally sanctioned by the United States for his links to the group, was due to be questioned on Thursday but had also said he would not turn up for the session. Hezbollah has said the charges smacked of "political targeting". Sawan had also faced opposition from Sunni prime minister designate Saad Hariri. (Reuters)